分析测试百科网

搜索

喜欢作者

微信支付微信支付
×

美国博士从事研究不端行为被抓,将面临3篇文章被撤稿

2021.8.18
头像

愿湫,十里亭

清风拂过十里亭,踏过春雪只待君。

  Viravuth Yin 博士是Mount Desert Island Biological Laboratory (MDIBL) 的副教授。科研诚信办公室 (ORI) 发现 Viravuth Yin 博士在美国公共卫生服务 (PHS) 等基金支持的研究中从事研究不端行为。

  Viravuth Yin有意、故意和/或伪造和/或捏造以下三 (3) 篇已发表论文和两 (2) 篇已提交手稿中的数据,从事研究不端行为。Viravuth Yin重复使用、重新标记和报告磷酸盐缓冲盐水 (PBS) 作为乱序反义锁定核酸 (LNA)的对照;Viravuth Yin通过不做或者是少做实验,得到相关的实验结果。Viravuth Yin同意接受2年的监督及撤回已经发表在Development,iScience 等3篇文章的要求。

  ORI对于科研诚信的调查案例及结果报告,这也能为中国的相关科研诚信部门等调查相关的案例,提供了借鉴。

  banquan13.jpeg

  Viravuth Yin 博士:基于Mount Desert Island Biological Laboratory (MDIBL) 进行的调查报告和科研诚信办公室 (ORI) 在其监督审查中进行的额外分析,ORI发现 Viravuth Yin 博士(被调查人),前 MDIBL 副教授,在美国公共卫生服务 (PHS) 等基金支持的研究中从事研究不端行为。

  Viravuth Yin既不承认也不否认 ORI 的研究不当行为调查结果。双方签订本协议以完成此事项,无需进一步花费时间、财务或其他资源。

  ORI 发现,Viravuth Yin有意、故意和/或伪造和/或捏造以下三 (3) 篇已发表论文和两 (2) 篇已提交手稿中的数据,从事研究不端行为:

  Smith AM, Dykeman CA, King BL, Yin VP. Modulation of TNFα Activity by the microRNA Let-7 Coordinates Heart Regeneration. iScience 2019;15:1-15; doi: 10.1016/j.isci.2019.04.009(以下简称“iScience 2019”)

  Smith AM, Dykeman CA, King BL, Yin VP. Modulation of TNFα Activity by the microRNA Let-7 Coordinates Heart Regeneration. iScience 2019;17:225-29; doi: 10.1016/j.isci.2019.06.017(以下简称“iScience Correction”)

  Beauchemin M, Smith A, Yin VP. Dynamic microRNA-101a and Fosab expression controls zebrafish heart regeneration. Development 2015;142:4026-37; doi: 10.1242/dev.126649(以下简称“Development 2015”)

  Smith AM, Dykeman CA, Yin VP. Modulation of epicardial TNFα Activity by the microRNA Let-7 Coordinates the Zebrafish Heart Regeneration. Manuscript submitted to iScience in 2018(以下简称“iScience 2018稿件”)

  Smith AM, Dykeman CA, Yin VP. Modulation of epicardial TNFα Activity by the microRNA let-7 coordinates the zebrafish heart regeneration. Manuscript submitted to PNAS in 2018(以下简称“PNAS 2018稿件”)

  具体而言,Viravuth Yin通过以下方式有意、故意和/或不计后果地伪造和/或捏造数据:

  在以下实验结果中重复使用、重新标记和报告磷酸盐缓冲盐水 (PBS) 对照作为乱序反义锁定核酸 (LNA):

  RT-qPCR data representing the knockdown of let7 expression in Figure 2B of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019

  images of tcf21:Dsred expression in LNA-let-7 treated hearts at 3, 14, and 21 days post -amputation (dpa) showing defects in wound closure in Figure 2C of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019

  quantification of tcf21:Dsred expression within the resection wound in LNA-let-7 treated hearts in Figure 2D of iScience 2019

  images exhibiting proliferating cardiac muscle (CM) in Figure 3A of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019

  suppression of CM proliferation indices in LNA-let-7 hearts at 3 and 7 dpa in Figure 3B of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019

  severity of the injured heart phenotype in Figure 3C of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019

  quantification of the severity of the injury heart phenotype in Figure 3D of iScience 2019

  electron microscopy images of remote and injury zones of resected 7-dpa hearts in Figure 4A of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, iScience 2019, and iScience Correction

  images of Tg(gata4:GFP) expression in the primordial heart muscle layer in Figure 4B of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, iScience 2019, and iScience Correction

  quantification of gata4:GFP expression in control and LNA-let-7 treated hearts in Figure 4C of iScience 2019 and iScience Correction

  RNA transcripts identifying differentially upregulated TNFα transcripts in Figure 5A of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, iScience 2019, and their resultant qPCR results, which identified increased TNFα expression in Figure 5C of PNAS 2018 draft, Figure 5B of iScience 2018 draft, iScience 2019, and Table S1 of iScience 2019

  CM proliferation analyses results in Figures S4B and S4C of PNAS 2018 draft and iScience 2018 draft, and Figures S5B and S5C of iScience 2019

  images representing the function of let-7 in Figure 2C of iScience Correction and reusing and relabeling images from an unrelated experiment, such that let-7 function is not represented in the image

  images reporting the function of let-7 in Figure 3A of iScience Correction

  images representing differences in the effects of miR-101a depletion on Met2 and PNA expression and the quantification of cardiomyocyte proliferation in uninjured control and Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) heat exposed hearts (CM proliferation analysis) in Figures 2A, 2B, 2C, and 2D, and results in Figure 2E of Development 2015

  muscle, fibrin, and collagen staining images representing increased scar tissue presence in Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) heat-treated hearts, as compared to wild type hearts in Figures 3A, 3B, 3C, 3D, 3E, and 3F of Development 2015

  scarring indices and the size of the injured area in wild type versus Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) heat-treated hearts in Figures 3G and 3H of Development 2015

  differences in (1) the amount of scarring, as represented by AFOG staining in control and Tg (hs:miR-101-a-sp) ventricles from resected and heat-treated hearts in Figures 4B and 4C; (2) the amount of scar tissue in the presence of suppressed miR-101a expression in Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) hearts, compared to control hearts in Figures 4H and 4I; and (3) the quantification of the scarring indices in control versus Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) hearts in Figure 4J of Development 2015

  differences in (1) the amount of scarring, as represented by comparing AFOG staining in control and Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) and Tg(hs:miR-133a1-pre) hearts exposed to long term heat therapy in Figures 5A, 5B and 5C, or Tropomyosin staining in Figures 5D, 5E, and 5F; and (2) the quantification of the scarring indices, tropomyosin expression, and injury area in Figures 5G, 5H, and 5I of Development 2015

  increased Fosab expression in Tg(hs:miR-101a-sp) ventricles relative to controls in Figures 6A and 6B, RNA in situ hybridization studies in control and regenerating hearts detecting miR-101a expression in Figures 6C, 6D, 6E, and 6E’, and Fosab expression in Figures 6F, 6G, 6H, and 6H’ of Development 2015

  images reporting significant differences in Dsred expression, cardiomyocyte proliferation, collagen and fibrin staining, and scar tissue removal in ventricles from zebrafish treated with lna-Let-7, as compared to scrambled control, to support the importance of miR-101a in scar tissue removal/ventricular regeneration in Figures 6H, 6I, 6J, 7C, 7D, and 7E of Development 2015

  报告未执行的研究方法和统计数据(以下实验结果)

  PCR data in the graph represented in Figure 2B of PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, and iScience 2019, by representing the data from two (2) remote PCR experiments as being from the same experiment

  PCR data in the graph represented in Figure 2B of iScience Correction by reusing and relabeling a graph containing data that were the result of different experimental conditions (exposure to heat shock), to include scrambled control data

  control data and statistical differences between control and experimental data represented in PNAS 2018 draft, iScience 2018 draft, iScience 2019, and iScience Correction, by falsely reporting the use of both antisense scrambled and LNA oligonucleotides that were designed and administered to adult animals via intraperitoneal injection at 10ug/g body weight

  representing the “n” of one biological replicate or one experiment as being multiple independent samples or experiments in iScience 2019 and iScience Correction

  control data and statistical differences between control and experimental data and the reported methods in Development 2015, concluding that miR-101a controls both CM proliferation and scar tissue removal, by falsely reporting the use of LNA oligonucleotides to modulate miR-101 activity in vivo to elucidate its contributions during adult heart regeneration

  Viravuth Yin签订了自愿和解协议(协议)并自愿同意以下内容:

  Viravuth Yin同意自 2021 年 8 月 2 日起对其研究进行为期两 (2) 年的监督。

  Viravuth Yin同意自愿退出 PHS 的任何咨询职位。

  作为本协议的一个条件,Viravuth Yin应该撤回Development 2015 Dec 1;142(23):4026-37;iScience 2019 May 31;15:1-15及iScience 2019 Jul 26;17:225-29等3篇文章。

  参考消息:

  https://ori.hhs.gov/content/case-summary-yin-viravuth-p-


Retraction
仪器推荐
文章推荐